Monday, October 24, 2016

Trump Set to Win Iron Range

A new poll released over the weekend, conducted by SurveyUSA, indicates Trump is set up for a staggering win on the Iron Range of Northern Minnesota.
SurveyUSA interviewed 650 registered voters from Minnesota’s 8th U.S. Congressional District 10/16/16 through 10/19/16, using registration based sample... Republican Donald Trump carries the district 47% to 35% over Hillary Clinton at this hour.
http://www.surveyusa.com/index.php/2016/10/24/in-re-match-in-minnesotas-8th-congressional-district-incumbent-democrat-nolan-an-underdog-19-days-to-go/

Now Trump winning a largely rural district practically anywhere else in the country by 12% wouldn't be news.  But the eighth congressional district of Minnesota isn't any fucking rural district.  This is the bluest of blue union country.  Cloquet, Grand Rapids, and International Falls are dominated by paper mills.  Hibbing and Virginia are the epicenters of American iron ore mining; the spawning grounds of the midwestern rust belt. Duluth and Two Harbors are major port cities. Five of the twenty Miracle on Ice players grew up here. As did Bob Dylan. This is as blue collar country as you'll get.


And Republicans simply don't win here.

They never have. And if you listen to the unions and the political establishment, they never will.

---

Minnesota's eighth congressional district boundary has shifted throughout the years. But the core of the district has always been the nine counties that traditionally make up northeastern Minnesota: Aitkin, Carlton, Cook, Itasca, Kanabec, Koochiching, Lake, Pine, and Saint Louis. The bulk of the population lives in Duluth or in the string of towns along the Mesabi Iron Range stretching from Virginia to Grand Rapids.


Iron Range counties in blue. Black line denotes boundary of MN-8.

From 1968 to 1996, the Democratic Presidential nominee averaged 66% of the two-party vote share in these nine counties.  This dropped a little starting with Al Gore. From 2000 to 2012, the Democrats averaged about 60% of the two-party vote share; still solidly blue territory, but not the place that gave Humphrey 71% of the two-party vote in 1968 even as he lost nationally.

Below is a chart of Democrat performance here relative to the state as a whole, and relative to the rest of the nation.

IR vs MN IR vs USA
1968 D+14 D+21
1972 D+10 D+19
1976 D+9 D+16
1980 D+12 D+19
1984 D+15 D+24
1988 D+11 D+19
1992 D+10 D+15
1996 D+8 D+12
2000 D+8 D+9
2004 D+9 D+12
2008 D+7 D+8
2012 D+7 D+9

The range has consistently delivered solid margins to the Democrats well above the state average, and significantly above the national average. While this gap has been closing, especially relative to the national average, there would still be a long ways to go at the current trend.

But what if Donald Trump, or more specifically, the Republican return to a more traditionally populist right-wing message, accelerates this trend? Then you might see something like what this weekend's SurveyUSA poll is predicting.

Now I'm well aware that Iron Range counties are well to the left of the rest of the eighth congressional district outside these counties.  In 2012, they were about eight points to the left of the district as a whole. But you don't go from an Obama+5 district in 2012 to a Trump+12 district in 2016 without a broad swing throughout the entire district. Assuming an even swing (which may not be the case as there's more room for Trump support to grow in the core range counties than in the already Republican counties along the fringe of the district), that would put Trump at +4 in the Iron Range. Which would be absolutely unprecedented for a Republican.

Now this poll might overstate Trump's support a little. A similar poll by SurveyUSA in October 2012 overstated Mitt Romney's support in the district. But I don't believe it's that far-fetched. The shedding of working class whites, and non-college educated whites, to the Republicans has been written about ad nauseum this election. But the losing the range, the epitome of working class white America, would be the ultimate dagger through the trade union's slice of the Democratic coalition.  Being run out by the upper middle class leftists and the financial elite, working class whites are almost left with no place in the modern day Democrat party. 

If the GOP had continued down the path of George Bush, John McCain, and Romney, this wouldn't be happening at this pace.  Displaced working class white's on the range would sooner drop out of the political process all together than join the party of wall street elite and multi-national corporatists responsible for shipping their mining and manufacturing jobs to Latin America and Asia.  But Trump has breathed fresh air into the GOP's prospects in lost and forgotten areas of the country like the range. In turning to sensible policies on immigration and trade, Republican's are opening themselves up to whole communities of voters they had completely alienated in the past.

If Trump wins the Iron Range, the realignment of American politics is more than fully underway